Best Sellers

Although we offer over 2000 shapes and sizes of metal cookie cutters to suit every occasion, there are many cookie cutters that are timeless classics and are always among our best sellers. The selections that appear in this section of our site change with the seasons. All of our cutters are made from steel manufactured right here in the USA, and our products have all been certified as food safe. Thanks for shopping with us!
  • $1.99
    Are you counting down the days 'til you're finally DONE with school?! Our Graduation Cap Cookie Cutter, 2 5/8" x 4...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    Take a bite out of our Apple Cookie Cutter. Present it as a teacher's gift or serve a platter of the cookies to...
    Qty.
  • Wedding Dress Cookie Cutter

    4.8 star rating
    $1.99
    Say "yes" to the Wedding Dress Cookie Cutter! Whether you're a bride-to-be, a fan of Cinderella, or just want to be...
    Qty.
  • Baby Onesie Cookie Cutter

    4.9 star rating
    $1.99
    Everyone at the baby shower will "ooh" and "ahh" over the 4 1/4" Baby Onesie Cookie Cutter. This very popular baby...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    You scream, I scream, we all scream, for ice cream! Celebrate the blissful hot day summer treat a soft serve ice...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    If you're stuck on what to use as a wedding or bridal shower favor, consider Ann Clark's Mason Jar Cookie Cutter-...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    Celebrate eternal love with our 3 3/8" Heart Cookie Cutter. Use for heart shape biscuits and other Valentine's Day...
    Qty.
  • Llama Cookie Cutter

    5 star rating
    $1.99
    Whether you prefer llamas or alpacas (llamas are larger and known for aggressively guarding spaces; alpacas are...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    From back-to-school to end-of-year, the 4" Pencil Cookie Cutter is a great tool to use for cookies and crafting! Use...
    Qty.
  • Diploma Cookie Cutter

    5 star rating
    $1.99
    Know someone who's graduating this year- or are YOU graduating? Celebrate the next stage of life- whether it's...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    Moooove everything else on the table over to make room for the adorable cow face treats. Pair this with other farm...
    Qty.
  • Strawberry Cookie Cutter

    5 star rating
    $1.99
    Enjoy sweet summertime with the 3 1/4" x 2 3/4" Strawberry Cookie Cutter. Strawberry shortcake, anyone? Bring a sweet...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    Life's a beach with the 4 1/8" Flip Flop Cookie Cutter from Ann Clark! Embrace summer by cutting out flip flop...
    Qty.
  • Seashell Cookie Cutter

    5 star rating
    $1.99
    She sells seashells on the seashore. Can you say that three times fast? The Seashell Cookie Cutter, 3 1/4", will...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    Enjoy a summer treat in many forms with Ann Clark's Popsicle Cookie Cutter. You can make and decorate cookies or cut...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    This vintage truck will be just the thing to please your antique-vehicle-loving friends and relatives. Pair it with...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    Put a ring on it! The 3 3/4" Diamond Ring Cookie Cutter is a pretty shape to use for a bridal shower or engagement...
    Qty.