Best Sellers

Although we offer over 2000 shapes and sizes of metal cookie cutters to suit every occasion, there are many cookie cutters that are timeless classics and are always among our best sellers. The selections that appear in this section of our site change with the seasons. All of our cutters are made from steel manufactured right here in the USA, and our products have all been certified as food safe. Thanks for shopping with us!
  • $1.99
    Celebrate eternal love with our 3 3/8" Heart Cookie Cutter. Use for heart shape biscuits and other Valentine's Day...
    Qty.
  • Arrow Cookie Cutter

    5 star rating
    $1.99
    Let Ann Clark's 4 1/2" Arrow Cookie Cutter point the way to terrific cookies. Make arrow shaped cookies and treats or...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    If you've been lovestruck, you will appreciate the Heart w/ Arrow Cookie Cutter, 3 3/4". Not a fan of Valentine's...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    Nothing says "I love you" like a heart shaped cookie! This beautiful scalloped heart will make the perfect cookie for...
    Qty.
  • $2.99
    Special delivery! Give that special someone a truck full of cookies made with love using this fun truck with heart...
    Qty.
  • Lips Cookie Cutter

    5 star rating
    $1.99
    Who says cookie cutters can't be romantic? Surprise your love with some Lips Cookie Cutters this Valentine's Day-...
    Qty.
  • Llama Cookie Cutter

    5 star rating
    $1.99
    Whether you prefer llamas or alpacas (llamas are larger and known for aggressively guarding spaces; alpacas are...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    You'll have the luck o' the Irish with this 2 5/8" Shamrock Cookie Cutter. Bring a platter of these traditional...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    Having a "Frozen"-themed birthday party? Use Ann Clark's 4 1/4" Winter Snowflake Cookie Cutter! This shape is perfect...
    Qty.
  • Mitten Cookie Cutter

    4.7 star rating
    $1.99
    Fight off the chill by making cookies with Ann Clark's 4" Mitten Cookie Cutter. Mitten cookies are fun to decorate...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    The bigger, the better. Our 5" Gingerbread Man Cookie Cutter is perfect for oversized holiday cookies. It could also...
    Qty.
  • Snowglobe Cookie Cutter

    5 star rating
    $1.99
    Embrace the magic of the holiday season with the 4" Snowglobe Cookie Cutter. There are innumerable ways to decorate...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    It's ok to goof around with this 4 1/2" x 2 1/2" cookie cutter- it's not fragile! The Christmas Leg Lamp is sure to...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    Bring your A-game to any holiday party with Ugly Sweater Cookie Cutter cookies. Also use this cookie cutter as a...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    O Christmas Tree, O Christmas Tree, how tasty are your branches! Welcome the holiday season with this 5" cookie...
    Qty.
  • $1.99
    If you're stuck on what to use as a wedding or bridal shower favor, consider Ann Clark's Mason Jar Cookie Cutter-...
    Qty.